"...we should pass over all biographies of 'the good and the great,' while we search carefully the slight records of wretches who died in prison, in Bedlam, or upon the gallows."
~Edgar Allan Poe

Monday, November 16, 2020

The 3-X Murders

"Brooklyn Standard Union," June 18, 1930, via Newspapers.com



A major reason serial killers such as Jack the Ripper, “Son of Sam,” and “Zodiac” have gained legendary fame is the fact that they (allegedly, in the Ripper’s case) wrote cryptic, taunting letters to the public, thus adding an element of mystery and intrigue to their evil acts.  Curiously enough, however, the murderer who wrote arguably the weirdest messages of all soon became almost forgotten.


The night of June 11, 1930, kicked off an eerie reign of terror in New York City.  19-year-old Catherine May and a grocer named Joseph Mozynski were sitting in Mozynski’s parked car on a street in Queens.  Then a man suddenly walked up to them and shot Mozynski dead through the open window.  The assassin then calmly pulled May out of the car and walked her to a bus stop.  Before leaving her there, he gave the girl a sheet of paper, warning her not to read it until the following day.


"New York Daily News," June 20, 1930



The paper had the name “Joseph Mozynski” rubber-stamped in red ink.  Under it was stamped “3X” and “3-X-097.”  Unintelligible as this message was, it did make it obvious that this was no random crime; the grocer had, for whatever reason, been targeted in advance.  The paper’s watermark failed to provide any clues to who might have bought it.


Shortly after this, the murderer began sending the “New York Evening Journal” letters signed “3-X” that were as verbose as they were bizarre.  He claimed to be “the agent of a secret international order” who had shot Mozynski in order to obtain “international papers” the grocer supposedly had in his possession, but, alas, his victim was not carrying them at the time.  Most alarmingly, “3-X” asserted that he would soon kill again in Queens.  His intention was to murder thirteen men and one woman.


If 26-year-old salesman Noel Sowley and 20-year-old Elizabeth Ring were aware of this ominous warning, they seem to have ignored it.  This was unwise.  On the night of June 17, the couple was sitting in Sowley’s car on a deserted back street in Queens, not very far from where Mozynski had been murdered.  (Although Ring had recently married, she and Sowley--an old flame--continued to see each other.)  A stranger walked up to the car, pointed a gun at Sowley, and ordered him to produce his driver’s license.  After studying it, the man announced, “You’re going to get what Joe got,” and fired two instantly fatal blasts into Sowley’s head.


As had been the case in the previous murder, “3-X” treated the female witness with a curious sort of gallantry.  After depositing a newspaper clipping about the Mozynski murder into the dead man’s pocket, the killer shepherded Ring to a bus stop and gave her yet another paper.  It was stamped in almost identical fashion as the paper he had given Catherine May.


"Brooklyn Times Union," June 18, 1930



Tests proved what everyone already suspected: that the two men had been killed with the same gun.  May and Ring described the murderer as about 5’6”, with a strong accent--Ring thought he was German.  He was in his thirties, with a thin face and “peculiar teeth.”


"New York Daily News," June 19, 1930



The day after Sowley’s murder, “3-X” sent the “Evening Journal” a note announcing that he was about to murder a man in College Point, Queens.  Naturally, that entire area quickly became what the “New York Times” described as “an armed camp.”  The streets of the Queens were packed with over 400 plainclothes detectives, two thousand patrolmen, and bands of motorcycle, auto, and gun squads.  It was the largest manhunt the NYPD had seen up to that point.


The police presence backfired by being just too obvious.  The murderer may have been insane, but he was obviously not stupid.  “3-X” was nowhere to be seen.  The police could only throw up their hands and warn couples to avoid parking in isolated streets--advice which was, at this point, probably superfluous.


On June 18, John Gallagher, the chief detective in Queens, received a 3-X letter:


For your information, one more of J. Mozynski’s friends was sent to meet him.

V-5 Solwey was shot near Floral Park and not very far away from police signal station.

I enclose the two empty shells--some of our money was found on his person and the N.Y. document.

The girl was, as in the case of Miss May, put aboard a bus and sent home--but no clues were left for you this time.  Thirteen more men and one woman will go if they do not make peace with us and stop bleeding us to death.

P.S. These facts have been disclosed to the New York Evening Journal.


The letter also mocked the police for failing to capture him.  As indicated in the note, the killer sent a similar letter to the “Evening Journal,” as well as Catherine May.  “3-X” told the “Journal” that “The young lady involved in this case is a victim of unfortunate circumstances.  Her story is clean.  I happen to know something of what happened Wednesday night.  Mozynsky was a rascal.  He had important papers belonging to us.  We feel sorry for his wife and children, but is for the best that they shall not know what he was.”


This remarkably wordy killer sent yet another letter to the police advising them that he had revised downward his projected death toll; he would murder only seven people instead of fourteen.  The maniac also warned that Mozynski’s brother would be killed if “the secret papers” were not returned.  The understandably terrified Mozynksi family insisted to detectives that they had no idea what the killer was talking about.


“3-X” then sent the “Evening Journal” his longest and nuttiest letter:


Dear Sir: "V. R. V8 of C. P. has returned the Philadelphia XV346 to me tonight after reading your paper--also 37,000 dollars of the black mail money--thanks to God--if I may use his name.


This means the following persons will be spared:


W. R. VS College Point.

S 12 College Point.

K 2 Brooklyn.

Z 3 (the woman in question, the tall blonde).

M 6 N.Y.C.

XX V (NYC Police Dept. Detective).

The following document still is missing--NJ 4-3-44--and 39,000 dollars for this document, the following people still are marked for death:

X-14.

X-7.

X-21. 

X-1.

Y-2. 

Y-4. 

L-6.


All initials withheld--too much of a clew for the super detectives of Bayside.


Mozinsky's number was R-9.

Sowley's number was X-4.


Please print this final message to the seven men left on the death list:


N. J. CCK-2-33-VV 3-K-RQS-4MLT-R. P. 49-6.


As in the Mozinski case, the girl with Sowley was sent home. She, also, proved to be an iron woman. I had to put the gun close to her breast to quiet her. She even tried to start the car.


But when I told her I would fire she then, to my surprise, began to say her prayers, and to prepare herself for death.


This saved her, as God is the only one I fear, and I could not shoot a woman showing such courage.


Both Miss Catherine May and this young lady are splendid women--I never thought there were such women in this life.


Well, I have told you that J. Moissett was innocent. Who was right? I repeat it again. Miss Catherine May is innocent. I have written to her mother about it. Here is something to prove it. On the night Mozynsky was shot I told Miss May that I was after some important papers.


I told her Mozynski had them, but I could not find them. I told her that Mozynski 'was a blackmailer and a drug peddler. I also asked her if she knew Mozynski and she told me no, that he just picked her up for a ride.


So I thought the girl would be o.k. and I burned some papers near the car, they were envelopes addressed to Miss Catherine May, but stained with blood so as not to leave any clews against the girl as I did not want her to suffer on account of me.


But it seems she forgot her coat and that's what lost her. Well, the poor girl is in a terrible mess now but I will do all I can to prove her innocent.


The shooting of Sowley should show it by now, and also a second warning to the rest. I know who the other girl is, and where she lives, and, as she happens to be of good family, she has nothing to fear, I never will reveal who she is. I have never seen women act like that before.


As for the detectives, and their commanding officer, to my estimate well, what's the use?


Sorry for them that's a black mark against them. But they never will find out who I am. One word from any one means death or a long term to state or federal penitentiary. Again thank you for your kindness.


I told Sowley's lady friend that we knew who we were after. No one needs fear me, only those marked for death, and I hope they heed the warning. I will not shoot any until they decide their own fate. I am only too glad to give them a chance.


I have been in the war. in the very thick of it, but to kill like this is terrible, but it had to be done.


We trailed Sowley as we knew he was in the habit of taking his girls there. I was on the highway waiting for him with A2 and M2 with M5 were trailing in our car behind. Sowley must have recognized me as he tried to run me over.


His business--you would like to know--well, here it is, everything--there is money, easy money, in it.


Does it not seem funny that both Mozinski, R9, and Sowley, X4, were very mysterious? Both are ladies’ men--and it takes a lot of money these days to keep ladies going.


There is a dead account in a Flushing bank, the money belongs to Mozinski. but it is not under his right name. We know where they got the money from. I did not like to shoot.


But, I sent a code signal for mercy.  Unfortunately the answer came back from the car “No--fire.” I had to obey, or get it myself. You see. I have turned up the king of diamonds.


A V 3 X)


P.S.S. Later I will explain the meaning of the triangle and the V.


This masterpiece of Crazy certainly drew a great deal of attention to the killer, but--even though his letters indicated he must have genuinely been somehow acquainted with his victims--they were of no help in establishing his identity.


On the night of June 19, hundreds of police again patrolled the streets of Queens in search of “3-X.”  At around 10:30, Morris Horwitz, president of the Municipal Underwriters insurance firm, sat in his car outside his Brooklyn home, talking to his wife, Rose, who was sitting on the porch.  Suddenly, a short, blond, “crazy-looking man” forced his way into the car.  He ordered Horwitz to move over to the steering wheel, “start the car and keep going.  If you don’t, I’ll shoot you.”  Before Horwitz could comply, the man shot him in the shoulder and fled.  Thankfully, Horwitz survived his injuries.  It was unknown if this was yet another attack by “3-X” or just a random robbery attempt.


“3-X” informed the “Evening Journal” that he had murdered one Harold Bridenbach (code name “X8W-9”) and that the body could be found on the Boston Road in the Bronx.  No body was found on the Boston Road, and, as far as the police could tell, no such person named Harold Bridenbach even existed.  The handwriting on the letter differed from the previous “3-X” letters, so it is possible this message was just an example of the sick hoaxes that surround all notorious crimes.  This was followed by a letter in the now all-too-familiar “3-X” writing threatening to kill actress Margalo Gillmore.  Fortunately, this plan was never carried out.


On June 21, the prolific “3-X” wrote the “Journal” that they would hear no more of him.  His work for the “Russian Red Diamond Society” was complete, and he was about to fly back to Europe in a secretly chartered airplane.  “Three X is no more,” he proclaimed.  “My mission is ended.”


In his farewell message, the killer claimed to be an ex-German army officer who during WWI, served in the Wilhelm St. office, Berlin.  He explained his coded signature.  “The first sign means A, the supreme tribunal of the order.  The second V it’s secret agent.  The two combined form the Red Diamond of Russia, a secret order all over the world.  Anyone breaking its rules is marked for death.”


He went on to say that the men he murdered had been dismissed from the order for treason.  One of his victims stole certain documents and tried to use them to blackmail certain of the Red Diamond agents in America.  “3-X” had been chosen by the order to punish, and, if necessary, kill the traitors.


On June 19, he explained, he recovered the documents he wanted, making it unnecessary to commit the third murder he had planned.  He added, “I am deeply sorry for having stained your country with blood...Quiet your people and tell them 3 X is no more.  If any more letters come they are fakes.  I am leaving today on my way back to Russia.  Please note I do not write U.S.S.R.  We do not recognize them.”


The murderer again paid tribute to the courage of Catherine May and Elizabeth Ring, and expressed how wounded he had been when one of the women described him as having “fish eyes.”  “I have no fish eyes--the police have fish eyes.”  He “signed” the letter “H.P. 12. W.A.”


Despite receiving this entirely rational and believable explanation for his actions, the police continued their hunt for “3-X.”  Who knew who might be designated next as a traitor to the Red Diamond.  For some time, they pursued increasingly weak leads.  Several days after the killer’s swan song, a drifter named Dewey Ede told police that at a restaurant outside of Coatesville, Pennsylvania, he met an oddly talkative stranger.  The man’s wallet contained a bunch of papers written in code.  According to Ede, his new friend confided that he had murdered two men in Queens and tried to kill a third.  He claimed to be “3-X,” chosen assassin of the Red Diamond of Russia.  He was on his way to Harrisburg, and then to New Orleans, where he would take a boat back to his homeland.  Ede’s description of the man matched those provided by other witnesses.  Was this “3-X,” or had Ede invented a nifty way to get his name in the newspapers?  No one could say.  It’s a very odd story, but then, we are dealing with one very odd killer.  Several men who, for various reasons, aroused the suspicions of the police were taken in for questioning, but May and Ring did not think any of them could be “3-X.”


On June 23, it briefly looked as if the murderer had broken his promise to leave the country and kill no more.  The police received a letter, purportedly from “3-X,” threatening to kill a Brooklyn man named Meyer Newmark if Newmark did not turn over document “U.J. 4-3-44.”  The coded signature differed slightly from earlier letters, but the handwriting seemed similar.  Fortunately, Newmark--who professed to have no idea why he was being targeted--remained unharmed.


The case faded from the newspapers until October 1931, when the police received a note warning “I am back.  I will pay every cop a visit.”  Handwriting experts believed it was a genuine “3-X” message.  If such was the case, the killer again failed to go through with his threat.


This proved to be the last anyone heard from “3-X.”  No one ever managed to even find a plausible suspect for these extraordinarily strange murders, and at this late date, it is virtually certain that no one ever will.

Friday, November 13, 2020

Weekend Link Dump

 

“The Witches’ Cove,” Follower of Jan Mandijn 


This week’s Link Dump is sponsored by some lucky black cats!





Sweden's ghost train.

Nottingham's cheese riot.

A Romanov saves a drowned man.

The unsolved murder of an unidentified mother and children.

Wales' version of the Blarney Stone.

More on that unscrupulous Norfolk artist.

The Great Wall of China wasn't always that great.

The very weird death (and life) of Jeffrey Lash.

A theory about why some people are allergic to penicillin.

Everything you've ever wanted to know about Napoleon's hair.

The birth of the smallpox vaccine.

Puerto Rico's weirdest mountain.

Verona's Juliet Club.

The earliest known twins.

The sexton of Spring Grove.

Archaeology and an ancient Pirate King.

A peep inside an asteroid.

In which the Prince Regent desecrates corpses.

The Wild West folklore surrounding a murdered prostitute.

Old newspaper stories about hidden treasure.

Spain really needs to give up art restoration.

Ballads of cross-dressing highwaywomen.

A casualty of the Haitian Revolution.

One really crazy murder case.

How California came to be named after a griffin-riding warrior queen.

A look at "The Canterbury Tales."

In which Prince Rudolph just can't stay dead.

A Manhattan literary cat.

Gli of the Hagia Sophia, RIP.

Marty of the Mount Washington Observatory, RIP.

The ancient Lady of Bietikow.

What it took for Victorian children to get sent to reform school.

Mortsafes and the Anatomy Act.

How a telephone caught a murderer.

Teddy Roosevelt writes a poetry review.

The ghosts of Hinsdale House.

A glued corpse.

The Queen of the Arctic Wild.

Thomas Cream, one of the odder serial killers.

A forgotten Victorian best-seller.

The astrological guide to Dumb Things People Do In Horror Movies.

A fatal pub brawl.

The burial of an ancient child.

Druids to the rescue!

That's it for this week.  See you on Monday, when we'll look at one of true crime's weirdest serial killers.  In the meantime, here's Gillian Welch.  I love this one.

 

Wednesday, November 11, 2020

Newspaper Clipping of the Day

Via Newspapers.com

 


This little poltergeist report appeared in the “Memphis Avalanche,” October 25, 1888:


Chicago, Oct 24 — A special dispatch from San Antonio Texas says: The people of Brownsville are greatly excited over the bombardment of a residence near that town by invisible hands, Last Friday night the light-keeper’s house at Point Pabel, occupied by Mrs Schreiber, widow of the late keeper, was struck by a shower of shingle nails.  The occupants paid little attention to it until the next night when about dark the shower of nails began again, this time more vigorously than before, varied by an occasional oyster shell and clod of dirt. 


People gathered, but could not tell where the missiles came from.  Last night the bombardment was continued, brick-bats being added to the shells and nails and every now and then an old scrap of iron or copper casting. Mrs Krountze, Judge Lightburn, and several others were struck and bricks rolled through the house or entered at a window. A crowd collected and a deputy sheriff from Brownsville who was sent down to investigate made a careful search but could discover no source from where the shower of missiles came. 


The superstitious mariners at the Point insist that ghosts are the offenders and that it is because this light, which is of great use to commerce, was put out by order of the lighthouse board through some difficulty in acquiring title to the land. As it is not in operation they firmly believe a legend started, that during the war it was put out one night by a light keeper in league with wreckers, and a schooner was enticed ashore, and stoutly maintain that the ghosts of the drowned sailors are kicking up the present trouble as a mark of their disapproval of the absence of this needed beacon. About ten years ago the house of County Clerk Glanenecke in Brownsville was similarly bombarded.


It was reported elsewhere that Mrs. Schreiber, weary of the spectral assault, moved in with a neighbor, but the bombardment merely transferred itself to that house.  I couldn’t find any other follow-ups to the story.


Monday, November 9, 2020

The Haunting at No. 16

Waterdales as it looks today


Poltergeist activity is usually clearly centered around one person: most often a child or teenager.  However, what makes the following case unusual is that the paranormal activity did not appear to be fixated on any individual, but on a house.

No. 16 Waterdales is a small, semi-detached residence in Northfleet, a town about twenty miles from London.  The house was built in the 1930s, and for years showed no sign of being anything other than the common run of unassuming council houses.  That all changed very suddenly and dramatically in 1962, when Mr. and Mrs. Sidney Maxted and their three young children moved in.


The first sign that something unusual was going on came only a short time after the family moved in.  When the couple was downstairs, they began hearing sounds like footsteps in the front bedroom, which was located directly above the living room.  It was as though someone was pacing back and forth over their heads.  The Maxteds did their best to persuade themselves that the sounds were merely caused by residents of the adjacent house.  Just the sort of thing that happens when two homes share a party wall.  Nothing to be concerned about.


Then the Maxted children began hearing scratching noises under their beds at night, and invisible hands yanking off their bedcovers and slapping them.  The disturbances became so frightening, the children insisted on sleeping in their parents’ room.


The Maxteds were far from happy at No. 16, but felt they couldn’t afford to give up housing that was both inexpensive and convenient.  They rapidly changed their minds thanks to one night in February 1965.  Around 2 a.m., Mrs. Maxted got up to change the diapers of her youngest child.  After dealing with the baby, she was startled to see a small child coming into the bedroom.  Assuming it was her four-year-old, Linda, she called the child’s name.  As the figure approached her, it suddenly increased in size, until it became a giant form looming ominously over her.  When she screamed, the thing instantly disappeared.


The Maxteds did not wait around to see what else the house had in store for them.  The following morning, they gave their notice and moved out.


The town council allocated the home to another young family:  Eric and Margaret Essex and their baby.  Eric had heard of what the Maxteds had experienced, but felt the need to have a good home outweighed the risks of possibly sharing it with a ghost.


Trouble for the new residents started out the same way it had with the Maxteds:  with the sound of mysterious footsteps in the upper bedroom.  As the days went by, the family was also troubled with strange and unpleasant moldy smells throughout the house.  They would also sometimes hear a low-pitched hum echoing through the rooms.


As had been the case with the previous tenants, the couple did their best to ignore these disturbances until they were confronted with something too frightening to overlook.  One night in August 1966, Eric was awakened by the now-familiar sound of footsteps, but this time located in the hallway and on the staircase.  When he went to investigate, he saw and heard nothing.  After he returned to bed, he began hearing a weird whistling sound.  Then the bed started shaking violently.  When he sat up, he was confronted by the figure of a woman in a long dress, glowing with an orange light.  A woman lacking her head.


The family fled the next morning, vowing they’d sooner live on the streets than go anywhere near that house again.


After word got out about this new horror, the council found they had a hard time finding tenants for No. 16, especially since neighbors continued to hear uncanny sounds emanating from the empty house.  Margaret Harrison, who lived in the adjoining house, often heard heavy footsteps going up and down the stairs next door.  One night, she heard a loud booming sound, as if some heavy object was thudding around the house.  The pounding noise then hit the hall ceiling, which was directly above her bedroom, followed by a noisy scraping sound.  It was as if something underneath her was trying to scratch or claw its way up into her room.  She was so frightened by the experience that she too moved out.


What makes this reported haunting even stranger is that it appears to have ended as inexplicably as it began.  A house that had been tenanted without incident for nearly thirty years suddenly became the site of paranormal terror.  Then, after about four years, it ended.  The house still stands today, with no further reports of any unusual activity within its walls.  This relatively obscure case is an excellent example of how the more one looks at poltergeist reports, the more difficult it becomes to find a “one-size-fits-all” explanation for the phenomenon.

Friday, November 6, 2020

Weekend Link Dump

 

"The Witches' Cove," Follower of Jan Mandijn


We're proud to say that for the first time, the Link Dump will be sponsored by some of our friends from across the pond!


California's haunted Whaley House.

It's now believed that man's best friend is man's oldest friend.

A Trotskyist spy vs. Joseph Stalin.  Guess who lost.

Eastbury Manor House and the Gunpowder Plot.

The murder that led to the legal Brady Rule.

A Satanic castle in North Carolina.

How Paris celebrated All Saints' Day in 1887.

How the condemned were prepared for the guillotine.

An English recipe for gunpowder.  It's probably best not to try this at home.

Guys, here is something you definitely should not do with a pin.

A reluctant countess.

A look at putting on plays in the 16th century.

More on the Black Loyalists of the Revolutionary War.

A famous UFO event in New Zealand.

Were Neanderthals and humans at war?

Ice Age mining camps.

The biggest heists of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.

How to dress like a Victorian maid.

Pepys on the Great Plague of 1665.

The strange Giant's Causeway.

The latest on Denisovan DNA.

A very weird hole in Bulgaria.

The life and mysterious end of Edward V.

The Golden Age of movie theaters.

The hermit of the Hollywood Hills.

The scandalous Madame Moustache.

Three ghost stories from old newspapers.

Burke and Hare's final victim.

A brief history of the Abominable Snowman.

A brief history of ballpoint pens.

The strange case of the Eriksson twins.

A photographer is haunting Europe's abandoned castles.

A handy guide to becoming a werewolf.

Life at sea in the 1860s-era Royal Navy.

The ghosts of Western Kentucky University.

Three much-photographed cats.

An apple pie bites the dust.

That's a wrap!  See you on Monday, when we'll visit a haunted council house.  In the meantime, this week in Russian Weird provides our musical selection.


Wednesday, November 4, 2020

Newspaper Clipping of the Day

Via Newspapers.com

 


This bizarre little news item appeared in the “Paterson Morning Call” on January 2, 1957:

Because a man who was buried alive there several months ago has vanished, residents of Sulmona, Italy, are giving a wide berth to one part of their town.


Raoul Hinay, 50, a Hungarian who had learned Yogi in India, visited Sulmona with a concert troupe and agreed to demonstrate his unusual powers by being buried alive before witnesses.  His hands were firmly tied, he was placed in a coffin and lowered into an 18-foot grave which was then filled with earth.  He was to remain buried for eight hours.  Witnesses included a doctor, judge, and the local police chief.  Eight hours later the coffin was brought up with the seals apparently intact.  The lid was removed.  The ropes were there but Raoul was gone.  No tunnel or other way out was in evidence--and the Hungarian never has been found.


I haven’t found any other source for this story, so it’s anyone’s guess how much--if any--of the story is true.


Monday, November 2, 2020

The Murders at Oddingley




“Justice delayed is justice denied” is an oft-quoted legal maxim.  However, I can think of few instances where this saying was more vividly illustrated than with an otherwise-commonplace murder which took place in the village of Oddingley, England. 


Our story opens on the morning of June 24, 1806.  Two men named Thomas Giles and John Lench were walking on a lane just outside of Oddingley when they heard a gunshot, followed immediately by a cry of “Murder!”  When they ran in the direction of these sounds, they encountered a man--a stranger to them--trying to hide in the field.  When they confronted him with the words, “Villain, what have you been doing?” the man replied, “Me?  Nothing.”  Then he dropped the bag he had been holding and ran off.


Not far from where this strange character had been lurking, Giles and Lench found something burning on the ground.  Closer inspection revealed it was a man.  After extinguishing the flames, Giles ran for help while Lench went in pursuit of the man they had seen.  Lench was able to nearly catch up with the stranger when the man put his hand in his pocket menacingly and threatened to shoot Lench if he came any closer.  As he himself was unarmed, Lench had little choice but to watch the miscreant make his escape.


When the County Magistrate, Reginald Pynder, arrived on the scene, he recognized the victim as Oddingley’s rector, George Parker.  Although the unfortunate Parker was still alive when Pynder saw him, he died a short time afterward without being able to identify his attacker.


Parker had been murdered in a particularly brutal fashion: he had first been shot, then clubbed over the head before being set on fire.  The bag his killer left behind was found to contain the gun used to slay the rector.


Although Parker was known for his kindly and helpful acts toward his parishioners, he was a far from liked man in certain circles.  He did not get a regular salary, instead depending on tithes from the villagers for his livelihood.  As he was a tight-fisted man very fond of money, he was most insistent on collecting these payments from the wealthier residents.  These tithes were usually paid from any produce or livestock owned by landowners.  However, the war with France had caused the value of such goods to soar, meaning that Oddingley’s landowners were paying Parker more than they thought was fair.  When they asked Parker to take their tithes in cash instead, Parker refused.  The rector’s popularity did not increase when he insisted that Oddingley’s farmers build him a barn, and then went on to complain about the cost of the dinners these men regularly held.  In short, Oddingley’s richest residents saw Reverend Parker as a very costly pest.


Giles and Lench described Parker’s murderer as of medium height, with balding dark brown hair and a black beard.  He wore a long blue coat with metal buttons.  This fit the description of one Richard Hemming, a carpenter who was already suspected of having committed several robberies.  Now, he was wanted for murder.  Unfortunately, although several people reported seeing Hemming at various places in the area, the police were unable to find him.  It was presumed he had managed to escape to America, although his wife Elizabeth maintained that he would never have gone away without telling her.


As Hemming was the only suspect in Parker’s killing, his disappearance necessarily left the murder investigation at a standstill.  The inquest returned the inevitable verdict of “Murder against some person or persons at present unknown,” and life in Oddingley went on  Hemming was eventually nearly forgotten by everyone except, one presumes, his wife and three children.


In January 1830, an old barn at Oddingley’s Netherwood Farm was demolished.  A laborer digging up the barn’s foundations found himself uncovering an old boot, still containing a skeletal leg.  When the site was excavated by police, they unearthed a man’s complete skeleton.  Buried with it were remnants of clothing and a few minor personal effects.


Everyone immediately recalled the long-missing Richard Hemming.  His wife was able to identify the boots and the items buried with the body as having belonged to her husband.  (As a side note, in one of life’s curious coincidences, the laborer who found the skeleton was Elizabeth Hemming’s brother.)


At the time Hemming disappeared, the owner of Netherwood Farm was one Thomas Clewes, so he naturally became the top suspect in the murder.  During the third day of the inquest into Hemming’s death, Clewes interrupted the proceedings by stating that he wished to make a statement.


Clewes then began singing like the proverbial canary.  He said that back in 1806, he and five other landowners, Captain Evans, John Barnett, Joseph Taylor, and William and George Banks, decided that something had to be done about Reverend Parker’s unseemly zeal for picking their pockets.  That “something” they settled on was murder.  The group paid Hemming--known as an unsavory sort who’d do anything for money--fifty pounds to kill the rector.  They even provided him with the gun to do the deed.  


Unfortunately for them, Hemming proved to be a dud as a hit man.  When the men learned that he had been caught virtually red-handed, they knew they had to prevent his arrest, as Hemming would surely seek to defend himself by saying he had been a mere hired gun.  The conspirators told Hemming to hide in Clewes’ barn while they made a plan to get him out of the area.  Hemming found out just too late that their “plan” was to have Joseph Taylor bash his head in with a mallet.  The men then quickly buried the body just outside the barn.  Clewes--who professed to have had no foreknowledge that Taylor would turn to murder--went on to say that over the years, the other men would give him money and other gifts to insure that he never “split” on them.


By the time of Clewes’ confession, Joseph Taylor, William Banks, and Captain Evans were dead.  (It was said that in the last few years of his life, the latter was tormented by terrible visions of...something.)  The surviving members of the alleged murder ring were arrested and charged with being accessories after the fact in the murders of both Hemming and Parker.  Clewes received an additional charge of having aided and abetted the killing of Hemming.


At their trial, the defense attorneys seized on a surprise legal complication: they pointed out that under English law as it had stood in 1806, the men could not be tried as accessories after the fact when the actual murderer had never been tried and convicted.  Legally, they said, it had not been proven that any murder had occurred at all.  This conundrum got the charges against Barnett and George Banks temporarily dropped, leaving Clewes as the sole defendant.


Those witnesses to the double murders who were still alive told their stories.  To the great displeasure of the defense counsel, Clewes’ confession was read out in court.  At the end of the trial, the judge summed up the unusual business as concisely as possible.  He advised the jury that they must reach their verdict only on the evidence heard in court.  The evidence dealing with Parker’s murder had been heard only because of its relation to the killing of Hemming, which was the only case under their consideration.  The judge went on to say that the only evidence against Clewes was his confession.  While this implicated him as an accessory after the fact, the judge was of the opinion that it failed to show that the defendant participated in, or even encouraged, the murder of Hemming.


Given the legal complexities involved, it is small wonder that the jurors were a bit confused.  They initially returned a verdict of “Guilty as an accessory after the fact,” but when the judge pointed out to them that Clewes was being tried for murder, they immediately delivered an acquittal.  The prosecution then said that they would not bother proceeding with their case against Barnett and Banks.


It is rare that murderers return home to a hero’s welcome, but such was the case in our story.  Most Oddingley residents were of the opinion that by ridding the world of Reverend Parker and Richard Hemming, the defendants had performed a notable public service.  A large party was thrown in their honor, and the three men remained esteemed local worthies to the end of their days.  When Clewes eventually became landlord of the Fir Tree Inn, he proudly decorated the walls with press cuttings about the murders.  The Fir Tree (popularly known as the “Murderer’s Bar,”) is still in existence, an unofficial monument to one of England’s strangest murder trials.