A lonely, isolated lighthouse. A raging nighttime thunderstorm. The lighthouse keeper suffers a violent, mysterious death…
If Ulman Owens isn’t perfect Strange Company material, I don’t know who is.
Since 1911, Owens had been the keeper of the Holland Bar lighthouse, off the Maryland coast. The 53-year-old widower normally performed his duties with efficiency, so when on the night of March 11, 1931, the lighthouse suddenly went dark--and during a hurricane, at that--the nearby community of Crisfield was naturally alarmed. As soon as the storm was over, the local Sheriff and a few other law enforcement officers went to the lighthouse to investigate. They assumed something had gone very wrong, but possibly the little group still wasn’t prepared for what they found.
Owens’ dead body was lying at the top of the circular staircase leading to the lighthouse cubbyhole. He was wearing only a shirt, and his body was covered in bruises. The rest of his clothing was in a bloody heap nearby. A deep gash was on his side, and a large welt was on his forehead. The lighthouse itself bore witness to what must have been a long and extremely violent struggle. Furniture was overturned, a chair was smashed to bits, and there were splotches of blood everywhere. A blood-stained knife was found on top of the stove.
All of this naturally led to the initial assumption that Owens was the victim of an unusually brutal murder. However, a further search of the lighthouse cast some doubt upon this theory. Three now-empty bottles of spirits of ammonia were found in the dead man’s bed, causing police to wonder if the lighthouse keeper, driven to madness by his isolated existence, poisoned himself with the ammonia and then tore apart his quarters during his death agonies.
 |
Holland Bar Lighthouse, circa 1950 |
The coroner, after a casual examination of the corpse, concluded that Owens had died of a heart attack, and the following day the body was buried in a nearby churchyard. Nothing to see here, move along.
Local residents felt otherwise. The prevailing opinion was that Owens had been murdered, and people became increasingly noisy about saying so. Such talk was further amplified when details about Owens’ surprisingly colorful private life began emerging. It turned out that Owens had been romantically involved with one Minnie Shores. Minnie was married and the mother of three, but she had been planning to get a divorce and marry her lover. However, Mrs. Shores may have been unaware that she was far from the only woman in Owens’ life. As unlikely as it may seem, our supposedly reclusive lightkeeper was quite the ladies’ man, surrounded by an army of infatuated women. According to the gossips, at least one of them was so jealous of Owens’ relationship with Minnie Shores that she was overheard making threats against his life. The question was asked: Did one of his many lady friends get a bloody revenge against Owens? Or was he murdered by a resentful husband? (Before you ask, the most obvious suspect, Minnie Shores’ estranged husband, had an unassailable alibi.)
The possible motives for why anyone would want to murder Owens began to grow quite impressively. His job as a lighthouse sentinel made him the natural enemy of the rum-runners who had to ply their trade literally under his nose. Furthermore, it was said that Owens had reported a number of these smugglers to Federal agents. Did one of these lawbreakers decide to shut Owens’ mouth…permanently?
Owens’ two adult daughters were adamant that someone had murdered their father, and insisted that the authorities reopen their investigation into the case. They pointed out that Owens had never suffered from heart trouble, and the extent of his injuries was so great, it would have been impossible for him to inflict them all on himself. Enough of a ruckus was raised for two agents from the Department of Justice to involve themselves in the mystery. Owens’ body was exhumed and a complete autopsy was finally performed. It showed that he had suffered a head wound brutal enough to crack his skull. Despite the presence of the bloody knife, Owens had no stab wounds. No poison was found in his organs, but he had an enlarged heart, which allowed local authorities to stick by their curious assertion that the lightkeeper had died a perfectly natural and unsuspicious death. All the blood found around the lighthouse? It was obvious: Owens must have had a nosebleed!
The two Federal agents were less convinced of this. They nosed around for a while, but wound up shrugging their shoulders and going back to Washington in defeat. And the Ulman Owens case was--however unsatisfactorily--closed for good.